Y Tu Mama Tambien (2001)(AKA "And Your
Mother Too")
Recipe for smash hit film: Two hot, young, teenage
boys on a road trip with a distraught woman with lots
of sex and bodily functions, drugs, alcohol and money
thrown in for good measure. That's what "Y Tu Mama Tambien"
has got going for it. Now, shut up and go see it. Don't
read anymore if you haven't seen the film because in
order to discuss it, I'm going to have to put in some
spoilers.
You know this is a Mexican film from almost the
beginning. Not just because everyone speaks Mexican
and it has subtitles but because the film is gritty,
realistic and sun dried. The colors are washed out in
decedent glory while the characters, two teenage boys,
smoke, drink, fuck and jerk off. In fact, the film begins
with a hot sex scene involving one of the lads and his
girlfriend. It be hard to get an American film like
this made because Americans are so fucking uptight about
teenage sexuality. It's important to note that writer/
director Alfonso Cuaron here includes numerous pissing
scenes, numerous sex scenes, much nudity, a fart scene,
and much talk of sex, masturbation and such things.
This film is debased because, as it so often reminds
us, its characters are real human beings here. The fact
that the film centers on two teenage boys makes it necessary
for the film to include "sophomoric" humor and dialogue.
That isn't to say "bad" but rather, base, real, unvarnished
humor and dialogue.
Cuaron is saying that this time in life is when
everything is base and he is correct. Only the young
can really discuss such basic human needs and functions
because they are old enough to know about them yet inexperienced
enough to not have become jaded, closeted or demurred
by polite society. This film is the sex-drenched, pubescent,
fun filled romp that I hoped "Nico and Dani" would be.
Here, the main characters of Julio and Tenoch are not
young lovers, but rather teenage boys who share some
sexual experiences (they jerk off together but do not
touch each other). When a real woman enters their lives,
through some pretty well-written contrivances, their
sexual knowledge (and ignorance) is exposed and they
begin on a wild romp to explore everything about human
sexuality that can possibly be known. They become men.
It sad that in Cuaron's vision, when the boys finally
do embrace their feelings for one and other and, through
the woman, make love to one and other it essentially
ends their friendship. Perhaps Cuaron is saying that
like exposed nerves, one touched, they recede into their
hiding places and never venture out again. The film
doesn't say that these young men are "gay," in fact
the apparently never express love for another man again
in their lives. But it does seem to express that it
is their culture (and all culture, really) rather than
their sexuality that keeps them apart. Cuaron even goes
so far as to have one of the boys vomit the next morning
after he has slept with his friend. That's a little
over the top. (Then again with drugs and alcohol also
a part of the evening, it could be attributed to that).
These are young man who, one evening, drop all their
macho pretenses and defenses and simply explore their
sexuality. It is important that the boys be open-minded
types. Cuaron has them call themselves "Charolastras,"
("Astral Cowboys"), because of the drugs they do. he
makes them totally debauched, sexually active, on drugs,
drinkers, and cheaters. These are not naive innocent
types who somehow get duped or seduced, nor are they
mere typical party animals. But rather they are explorers,
of a sort, reaching out for life experiences and trying
to figure out what it is all about.
Cuaron uses tons of Mexican imagery to suggest
his idea of life being temporary and momentary. This
is integral to the plot. The theme suggest that the
young should explore the world via sex and drugs in
order that they might mature and become fully realized
human beings. Cuaron uses the political system in Mexico
to delineate the boys as different. One is from a wealthy
family, one is not. Neither boy is better than the other
or really all that different from the other. Cuaron
suggests that this "evolution" of male experience is
not necessarily about the class structure. All young
men might go through it. He also constantly reminds
us of the tenuous political nature in Mexico, again
suggesting that freedom, like life, is a temporary and
transitory thing. It is important to reach out and grasp
experiences while we can before some political or cultural
upheaval makes such experiences obsolete.
Cuaron also obsesses over death in the film. Continually
images of death remind us of how fragile and tenuous
life is. These moments we experience are fleeting. We
could be dead tomorrow. Better to reach out for something
today, even if we regret it later, rather than never
to experience it at all. This revelation is embodied
not only in the numerous crosses that appear in the
roadside during the film but in the central character
of Luisa as well.
Cuaron's film is a wonderful and free-wheeling
adventure. The director makes all he does seem easy
and flowing yet it is also obvious that he stressed
over every detail. Not a moment exists here that isn't
integral to the story or themes. No time is ever truly
wasted. Cuaron may spend a bit too much time with narrated
asides that don't truly mean much to the story at hand
but these little dialogues somehow serve to generally
propel the themes and ideas of the piece. It is important
and through it we learn a few things about the characters
that we might not otherwise know.
The acting in the film is superb. It is often hard
to judge acting in a foreign film when one does not
speak the language. But it is obvious here that Cuaron
has hired three of the best actors in Mexico to be in
his film and they perform admirably. Gael Garcia Bernal,
the handsome young man from "Amores Perros" is again
awesome here. This boy needs to learn English (if he
doesn't already know it) and come to America immediately.
He will be huge. His sexuality and his pure and unabashed
emotional acting will make him a huge star. Likewise,
Diego Luna, who had a small role in "Before Night Falls"
proves himself to be right on par with Bernal. As hunky
and as superb of an actor as his costar, Luna's physicality
and more reserved manner will propel him into heights
of thespian grandeur the like of which we have never
seen. These two young men are not only perfect actors,
but their chemistry practically causes explosions on
the celluloid. Someone told me that they were friends
in real life. Whether they are or not, their work here
is staggering. These young men will not disappear from
sight any time soon.
Likewise Maribel Verdu, who has appeared in over
40 movies, proves her immense talent in every scene
she is in. Forced into the role of weepy wife a few
too many times in the film, her characters motivation
for such hysterics becomes clear at the film's end and
we realize just how perfect her performance is. Unafraid
and daring in a role which requires nudity and (one
assumes) faux intercourse with teenaged boys, Verdu
proves herself an actress of immense talent. Her ability
to shine equally along side Bernal and Luna when the
three of them are on screen is a testament to her skills.
Note:
The songs "By This River" by Eno and "Watermelon
in Easter Hay" by Frank Zappa are used in the film.
The highest grossing film opening in Mexico's history.
$2.2 million in one week.
Although nominated for a Golden Globe, Mexico chose
not to submit it for an Academy Award.
|
Report
Card
Script:
A+
Acting: A+
Cinematography\Lighting: A+
Special Effects\Make Up: A+
Music: A+
Final
Grade: A+
|
And
Help Support Filethirteen!
Get
Your "Y Tu Mama Tambien" Stuff...
|
More
of Lodger's reviews indexed alphabetically! Just
click your favorite letter to go there.
a
b c
d e
f g
h i
j k
l m
n o
p q
r s
t u
v w
x y
z
HOME
|
|